BEB 109 CRITICAL THINKING
Assignment: E-Portfolio - Reflection on Problem Solving
The problem I chose to address is water wastage caused by overflowing storage tanks and poor monitoring of water levels.
I have noticed that in many homes and institutions, water pumps are still controlled manually. Someone has to check the tank and switch the pump on or off. Sometimes the person forgets that the pump is running, and the tank starts overflowing. In other cases, people only realize that the tank is empty when there is no water coming from the taps.
Apart from wasting water, overflowing tanks can also waste electricity because the pump continues running even when the tank is already full.
I therefore asked myself:
Can I develop a simple and affordable system that automatically monitors the water level and controls the pump?
Before thinking about the solution, I considered the people who experience this problem. These include homeowners, caretakers, plumbers, maintenance workers and people responsible for managing water in institutions.
Their main concern is having water available when they need it without constantly checking the storage tank.
For example, a caretaker may have several other duties and may not always remember to switch off the pump. A homeowner may also not know that the tank is almost empty until the water supply stops.
From this, I identified some important user needs. The system should be:
Simple to operate
Affordable
Reliable
Safe
Easy to maintain
Able to reduce unnecessary water wastage
The solution should make water management easier rather than introducing another complicated system for the user.
After understanding the problem, I thought about different ways it could be solved.
Some of the ideas I considered included using a normal float valve, installing a float switch, using electronic water-level sensors, using an ultrasonic sensor or developing an automatic pump-control system.
I also considered adding indicators that would allow the user to see whether the tank is empty, half-full or full.
After considering the different ideas, I decided that a simple automatic water-level monitoring and pump-control system would be a practical solution.
The basic idea is simple: when the water level becomes low, the system switches the pump on. When the tank becomes full, the system automatically switches the pump off.
Instead of immediately installing the system on a large water tank, I would first develop a small prototype.
The prototype could use a small water container to represent the storage tank, together with water-level sensors or float switches, a small pump, a relay/controller and indicator lights.
The system would operate as follows:
Low water level → Pump switches ON
The pump continues filling the tank.
Full water level → Pump switches OFF
I would also use simple indicators to make the water level easier to understand. For example, red could indicate a low water level, yellow could indicate a medium level and green could indicate that the tank is full.
Building a small prototype first would allow me to identify problems without spending too much money on a full-scale system.
After developing the prototype, I would test it under different conditions.
First, I would lower the water level and check whether the pump switches on automatically. I would then allow the container to fill and observe whether the pump switches off when the maximum level is reached.
I would repeat the test several times to check whether the system works consistently.
I would also allow a few potential users to observe or interact with the prototype and ask them questions such as:
Is the system easy to understand?
Are the water-level indicators clear?
Would this system be useful to you?
What would you change or improve?
Their feedback would help me identify weaknesses that I might not have noticed myself.
I would not expect the first prototype to be perfect. If I discovered problems during testing, I would make improvements and test the system again.
For example, the first prototype might successfully switch the pump on and off, but users might find it difficult to know the current water level. I could improve the second prototype by adding indicator lights.
Another problem might be that some electrical components are exposed to moisture. I could improve the design by placing the control components inside a suitable protective enclosure.
The process would therefore continue as:
Develop → Test → Receive feedback → Improve → Test again
I would repeat this process until the system operates reliably and meets the needs of its intended users.
Working through this problem shows me that innovation does not always mean creating something completely new. Sometimes innovation involves looking at an everyday problem and finding a simpler, safer or more efficient way of solving it.
In this case, the main problem is not just an overflowing water tank. It is the need for a better way of managing stored water without depending entirely on someone to monitor the tank manually.
By understanding the users, considering different solutions, developing a prototype, testing it and making improvements, I can gradually develop a solution that could reduce water wastage, save electricity and make water management easier.
The activity also shows how critical thinking, creative thinking, design thinking, prototyping and iterative development can work together to solve a real-world problem.